This summer's Cleveland Public Theatre troupe has a production [1] with all the right elements--a sword fight, mermaids, pirates and, of course, Captain Hook, Peter Pan, Wendy and Tinkerbell.
If you missed the magical performance in the beautiful Brooklyn Centre neighborhood [2]--there are more performances scheduled. Pack a picnic and bring the kids.
Links:
[1] http://www.cptonline.org/theater-show.php?id=185
[2] http://realneo.us/content/independence-day